• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Benny’s Pizza

At Benny's Pizza, we craft a slice of joy that brings families and friends together. Nestled in Wenonah, NJ, our story is rooted in passion, quality, and community. Our menu features not just the best pizza in South Jersey, but also beloved cheesesteaks, cheesy fries, and mouthwatering mozzarella sticks, all praised by our loyal customers for their bold flavors and outstanding value. We pride ourselves on excellent service and a welcoming atmosphere, making it the perfect spot for both takeout and a delightful dining experience. Come and taste why Benny's Pizza is a cherished local favorite.

Benny’s Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Tammy M.
Tammy M.

The best mozzarella cheese sticks recommend highly delicious. The best pizza recommend I delicious the best cheesesteaks recommend all delicious. Everything's good.

Christina M.
Christina M.

Been here a few times...always great pizza and excellent service. We usually get just pizzas. Tasty, tasty, tasty.

Lisa K.
Lisa K.

We order from here a lot-they have good food at a decent price with quick pick up or delivery!

Jennifer K.
Jennifer K.

Best local cheesesteaks at a good price. Cheese fries are good too. Lots of yummy options. Good service

AJ B.
AJ B.

Best pizza, cheesesteaks, and cheese fries in South Jersey. Every time I come to visit I order 2 triple cheesesteaks a day. I've loved them since I was a kid. Great staff as well. When I was deployed to Afghanistan they sent me care packages. The owners and staff are amazing people. I highly recommend them.

Monica C.
Monica C.

I honestly wish there were 10 stars so I could rate them a 10/10 because this pizza place has AMAZZZZZZZING FOOD!!!! Even their Salads are Delicioussssss!!!! At one point, I was ordering their chicken Caesar salad which is Chock FULL of PERFECTLY seasoned grilled chicken and everything is fresh! Then, my stepmom took a bite.... And she started ordering practically 3 times a week. They also make their own honey mustard dressing that is enough to make your mouth Water!! Just thinking about it, right now, I'm about to Drool! My husband adores their Meat lovers pizza and omggggggg. The crust alone is like crushed velvet in your mouth. The sensation is amazing and I know it sounds very odd but.... Lol it is like they Literally PUT ALL Of Their Love and Passion into your Food! Personally, my mom and I are Cheesesteak fans and there's Doesn't Disappoint, at All. Better than any other steak out there. Everything from their rolls to the meat. They don't skimp on packing your sandwich full of flavor and deliciousness. I cannot wait to return for their delicious food Hmmmm, maybe Next week! Don't forget to say Hello to Benny and their Staff! They're super nice and treat ya just like a family! Bon Appetit!

James P.
James P.

947th different cheesesteak eaten in the last 4 years. New Top 5 favorite guest eater Liz and her Dan. I tell their story in the long video on YouTube. We got a Mushroom Cheesesteak, Garlic Bread cheesesteak and Dan's order extra cheese, bacon and hot peppers from Benny's Pizza and took them to Eight and Sand Brewing. These were standard Pizza shop cheesesteaks. Dan has the right idea to add stuff/flavor to this cheesesteak. I like Eight & Sand. Nice selection of Beers. They have a very sour sour draft. I got the less sour sour. They opened 15 minutes early, gotta love that!!

Kristin H.
Kristin H.

I grew up going to bennys and just moved back. we've tried A LOT of pizza restaurants in the past year and keep coming back to bennys. It's the best in the area. I love their white pizza and their cheese pizza is perfect.

Joe L.
Joe L.

Bennys was a great place. Chicken cheesesteak was fantastic. Homemade Mozz sticks were really impressive and homemade. Need to come back and try the cheesesteak. If its anything like the chicken cheesesteak may end up being my go to.

Location

Welcome to Benny’s Pizza, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of Wenonah, NJ. Known for its exceptional offerings, this eatery is a haven for pizza lovers and comfort food enthusiasts alike. Located at 1056 Mantua Pike, Benny's Pizza stands out not just for its delicious food, but also for a warm atmosphere that welcomes families and friends.

Benny’s Pizza excels in delivering more than just food; it offers a community experience. The establishment caters to various dining preferences, providing options for delivery, takeout, and even outdoor seating. There's something here for everyone—whether you're craving a quick weeknight dinner or a leisurely meal with friends under the stars.

What makes Benny's truly special is the exceptional quality of its dishes. Customers rave about the mozzarella cheese sticks and the cheesesteaks. One loyal patron, Tammy M., praised the mozzarella cheese sticks as the “best” she’s ever had, while AJ B. fondly recalls Benny’s cheesesteaks as a childhood favorite, reminiscent of a strong community bond, where even deployed soldiers received care packages from the generous staff.

The pizza itself is a highlight, earning continual praise from satisfied customers like Christina M., who asserts that it is “always great.” Each slice boasts a perfect balance of crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and ample cheese that together create a mouthwatering experience. Lisa K. captures the essence of Benny’s as a reliable spot for grabbing food that is both satisfying and reasonably priced—ideal for busy families or groups wanting a delightful meal without breaking the bank.

Beyond just the food, Benny's Pizza provides a friendly atmosphere with moderate noise, making it suitable for families and groups. The restaurant even has a TV for those who want to catch a game while enjoying their meal. And yes, they accept credit cards for added convenience.

So whether you're a lifelong local or just passing through, make sure to visit Benny's Pizza for an unforgettable experience that’s certain to leave your taste buds dancing. With their rich selection of pizzas, cheesesteaks, cheese fries, and good service, Benny’s Pizza truly embodies the spirit of excellent local dining.

  • Offers Delivery
  • Offers Takeout
  • Takes Reservations
  • Accepts Credit Cards
  • Family-Friendly Environment
  • Outdoor Seating Available
  • Good for Groups
  • Alcohol Served
  • Bike Parking Available